Newsletter ·
The “Real Work” Can Wait: Why Your First One-on-Ones Are Breaking Trust
When a new person joins the team, our default is to rush straight into the backlog. But treating human connection as an unstructured afterthought is exactly why teams stay stuck in silos.

When a new person joins the team, our default is to rush straight into the project backlog and role expectations. But treating human connection as an unstructured afterthought is exactly why teams stay stuck in silos.
The Trap
You step into a new environment, or a new person joins your team. The pressure is on, and the backlog is overflowing. What happens in that very first one-on-one? The default corporate trap is to dive straight into the “real work”—the org chart, the current crisis, the tools, and the immediate expectations.
We assume that if we just get the tasks aligned, the relationship will sort itself out organically over time. We add “getting to know them” to a mental backlog that we rarely revisit. By skipping deliberate connection, we silently reinforce an invisible parent-child dynamic where the manager or senior team member dictates the agenda, and the new colleague simply nods along. We treat people as resources to be allocated rather than adults to build a shared system with, and we wonder why it’s so hard to build trust when a real crisis hits later.
The Reframe
Getting to know someone isn’t a “soft skill” or a luxury you get to when you have spare time; it is the foundation of a resilient working system. If you value transparency, workflow, and structure in your projects, why wouldn’t you apply the same visibility to building a relationship?
Instead of an awkward, unstructured chat where the person with the most authority does all the talking, you can co-create the conversation. Make the work of discovering each other visible, structured, and evenly distributed. You don’t need a corporate ice-breaking retreat; you just need to manage the conversation the same way you manage your work.
The Practice: The Discovery One-on-One
I call this the Discovery One-on-One, a core practice from my book, Changing Your Team From the Inside. Here is how you can use it to build immediate shared power the next time you meet a new team member.
Set up a simple Kanban board (either on a table with sticky notes or on a shared virtual board) with three columns: To Do, In Progress, and Done.
Create five topic cards and place them in the To Do column. As you discuss each one, physically (or virtually) move the card from To Do, to In Progress, and finally to Done:
- Ice Breaker: Take turns asking three non-work questions (e.g., “What do you spend most of your spare time doing?” or “If you could do anything in the world other than your current job, what would it be?”). You only get three questions each, so make them count.
- Professional Background: Share the history that led you both to your current roles.
- Domain Experience: Gauge their past experiences with your team’s specific way of working (like Agile). This is critical: it quickly uncovers hidden fears, bad habits, or assumptions carried over from past toxic environments.
- 3 Wishes: Ask, “If you could have three wishes for transforming your daily work or workplace, what would they be?” This gives you an immediate read on their mindset and what they value most.
- ??? (Wildcard): Leave an open space for any topic they want to bring to the table.
The Proof in the Field
When I share this exercise, people often tell me they are excited to try it, but they leave it in their backlog of “things to do eventually.” But those who take action see immediate shifts in team dynamics.
Mario Esposito, a UX Designer who read the book, decided to stop waiting and put the Discovery One-on-One into practice. He adapted it for his team, even printing custom cards and adjusting the experience section to cover past, present, and future.
The results were instant. As Mario shared with me:
“I used it once again today, for the onboarding of a new collaborator who had just joined the team… I tell you only that after 40 minutes we were already like two best friends! Really powerful this workshop!”
A Practical Takeaway
The tl;dr: Stop treating the first one-on-one as a one-way task delegation meeting. Co-create the conversation with a simple structure to build an immediate foundation of trust.
The Mantra: The “real work” can wait 40 minutes. Building the team cannot.
The Coaching Prompt
Before your next one-on-one with a new team member, ask yourself:
- Are you defaulting to authority? In your one-on-ones, who owns the agenda, and does it leave room for mutual discovery?
- What assumptions are you making? Are you assuming their past work experiences and definitions of success match your team’s current reality?
- How can you make connection visible? Instead of hoping for organic relationship building, what structure can you introduce tomorrow to guarantee it happens?
🎁 A Holiday Gift for You & Your Team
Building intentional team dynamics and shared power is exactly why I designed the Team Alignment and leadership workshops, which evolved from practices just like the Discovery One-on-One.
As a holiday season gift to this community, I am giving away a few free Lunch and Learn sessions based on the Emerge Labs curriculum. You can choose from the catalog here.
We will schedule these in January or February 2027 to help your team kick off the new year with clarity, alignment, and better conversations.
If you want to claim one of these slots for your team, book a quick chat and let me know! What team dynamics or onboarding friction points are you currently trying to navigate?